Johann Carl Wilhelm β€œCarl” Witting

πŸ”— Share

Johann Carl Wilhelm β€œCarl” Witting

Born 1822-12-09
QuadenschΓΆnfeld, Landkreis Mecklenburgische Seenplatte, Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, Germany
Died ?
Dunedin, Dunedin City, Otago, New Zealand
Cemetery Andersons Bay Cemetery (Andersons Bay) Β· Dunedin City
Buried ?
Andersons Bay Cemetery, Andersons Bay, Dunedin City, Otago, New Zealand
πŸ“ Research Notes
This is a placeholder entry until Carl's date of death can be established. He was admitted to Dunedin Lunatic Asylum in 1873 and discharged later that year. It was assumed he died there and was buried in the unmarked mass grave at Andersons Bay Cemetery for those who died at Seacliff, but this is now thought to be unlikely. RESIDENT MAGISTRATE'S COURT. (Before H. McCulloch, Esq., R.M.). Carl Witting, a settler on the North Road, husband of the woman lately convicted of drowning three of her children, was charged by the police with being a dangerous lunatic at large. Albert Witting, son of the accused, a lad 15 years of age, gave evidence to the effect that his father's conduct had been very strange for many years, and of late had become more so. On the previous Friday the accused had chased witness with a hammer, threatening to knock his brains out. He had given him no provocation. Witness was afraid to come back to the house, and slept in an out-house belonging to a neighbor. The other children had frequently been turned out of the house and kept out all night by the father. The accused was restless at night, and wandered about, instead of sleeping. He was very violent, and broke out in a furious passion frequently without any provocation. The accused, who said he did not feel able to stand, and had been accommodated with a chair, was then asked whether he desired to put any questions to the witness, when he broke out in an ungovernable paroxysm of rage, violently shaking his fist in the direction of the bench, and denouncing his children, the police, and the magistrate in a torrent of broken English expletives. As he could not be prevailed upon to be silent, he was forcibly removed by the police, and locked up. William Russell, solicitor, residing on the Bay Road, stated that he had known the accused for ten years, and gave further evidence to the effect that his habits were such as to indicate mental unsoundness. He was under the impression that the public were conspiring against him, and particularly that people were always trying to steal his cattle. Mrs Witting once mentioned to witness that her husband had been in a lunatic asylum in Germany. Witness considered that the accused was of unsound mind and dangerous. Peter Myers, laborer, had known the accused for some years, considered him strange, and would not live alone with him for all New Zealand. The accused was remanded for medical examination. Source: Southland Times (7 March 1873). The following particulars as to the mental condition of the Prussian named Carl Witting, whose wife lately murdered her children, are given in one of the Southland papers: β€” "Since the conviction of his wife the man has removed from the cottage he then occupied to one which he has had built for him, upon the north road, his son, of about 17 years of age, and three daughters living with him. Of late he has become very violent and dangerous β€” in fact, utterly unmanageable, and a terror to the neighborhood. Screams have been frequently heard from the house, and upon two or three occasions the children have been out of doors at night. This was the case on Saturday night, 1st inst., when Witting was so perfectly outrageous that refuge had to be taken with the neighbors, and the police were appealed to. It appeared from evidence that the threats of the accused, and his language and behaviour generally, had been of the most fearful character, and that, he brandishing an axe, it had been a wonder the lives of some had not been sacrificed. In the Court the accused was very violent, and had to be removed. These events have tended materially to prove that the tide of public sympathy in favor of the wife, after her conviction, was not misdirected, and go very far to point out the inflictions to which the poor woman must have been long subjected, and which terminated so tragically." Source: Grey River Argus (28 March 1873). Germany, Lutheran Baptisms, Marriages, and Burials, 1500-1971 Name Johann Carl Wilhelm Witting Event Type Taufe (Baptism) Birth Date 09 Dez 1822 (9 Dec. 1822) Baptism Date 12 Dez 1822 (12 Dec. 1822) Baptism Place Mec, Mecklenburg, Deutschland (Germany) Father Johann Witting Mother Friederica Witting New Zealand, Naturalisations, 1843-1981 Name Carl Witting Former Nationality Prussian Occupation Farmer Residence City Invercargill Naturalisation Date 25 Dec. 1856 File Number 1861/1052 New Zealand, Electoral Rolls, 1853-2010 Name Carl Witting Electoral Year 1866-1867 Residence Place Invercargill, New Zealand District Invercargill Region or Province Southland

240.5 KB Β· Uploaded Nov 12, 2026 Β· by Admin

Also in Andersons Bay Cemetery (6)

πŸ“·
Frances Anzac Palmer
πŸ“·
Elizabeth Cramond
πŸ“·
Rona Leanor Rhoda Port
πŸ“·
Douglas Shand
Edward Arthur β€œTed” Phillips Edward Arthur β€œTed” Phillips Caroline Brown Anderson Caroline Brown Anderson
View all in this cemetery β†’