Jane Angus McLeod
Jane Angus McLeod
| Born | 1836 |
|---|---|
| Died |
1871-02-14 Christchurch, Christchurch City, Canterbury, New Zealand |
| Cemetery | Addington Cemetery (Christchurch City) Β· Canterbury |
| Buried |
? Addington Cemetery, Addington, Christchurch City, Canterbury, New Zealand |
| Plot | Block 0, Plot 371A. |
EXIF Data (13 fields)
| Camera Make | samsung |
|---|---|
| Camera Model | Galaxy A54 5G |
| Orientation | 1 |
| Software | A546EXXS9CXG2 |
| Date Modified | 2024:08:12 16:07:26 |
| Shutter Speed (s) | 0.01 |
| Aperture (f/) | 1.8 |
| ISO | 40 |
| Date Taken | 2024:08:12 16:07:26 |
| Focal Length (mm) | 5.54 |
| Latitude | -43.543284 |
| Longitude | 172.623029 |
| Altitude | 39 m above sea level |
π Research Notes
WOUNDING WITH INTENT TO MURDER. Press (16 February 1871, p. 3). INQUESTS. Murdered by Husband Hugh McLeod. Lyttelton Times (21 February 1871, p. 3). SUPREME COURT. WILFUL MURDER. Press (13 March 1871, p. 3). THE CONVICT MCLEOD. Press (18 March 1871, p. 2). That trial was followed by the trial of Hugh McLeod for the murder of his wife. Given that there were statements by the accused that he had stabbed her, the defence tried to argue that death may have resulted from some other condition. Although the defence expressly disclaimed any reliance on provocation, there was evidence that the victim had worked as a prostitute in Christchurch for some time, during much of which the accused was working in country districts. He had however spent some time living with her in a brothel. The accused, who had been drinking heavily for months, was also somewhat intoxicated at the time. The jury found a verdict of murder, recommending him to mercy on the basis of his prior good character and the provocation offered by his wife. That recommendation was forwarded by Gresson J to the Governor and may well have been instrumental in McLeod having his death sentence commuted. Source: Canterbury Law Review [Vol 11, 2005] 'NOT HAVING THE FEAR OF GOD BEFORE HER EYES': ENFORCEMENT OF THE CRIMINAL LAW IN THE SUPREME COURT IN CANTERBURY 1852-1872 JEREMY FINN AND CHARLOTTE WILSON. One major source of friction arose from the trial of Hugh McLeod for the murder of his rowdy and drunken prostitute wife Jane in January 1871. Drs Prins and Patrick had conducted the autopsy and noticed that two of the knife wounds to the ribs were connected: a finger could be passed between them. The knife had apparently cut the right lung and collapsed it. The right side of the chest cavity was filled with blood, but there was surprisingly little sign of inflammation where the knife had penetrated the lung. Death was attributed to loss of blood and exhaustion. However, the defence had asked Drs Nedwill and Frankish to conduct a separate post mortem examination, and they came to a different conclusion. The wound to the lung need not have been fatal, as no major blood vessels had been cut. The victim's liver was greatly enlarged, which reflected her years of alcoholism, and her heart was flabby. Nedwill testified that he had known patients with a collapsed lung to survive for many years. He suggested that the cut in the lung had been made by accident during the first autopsy, as there was so little inflammation. Dr Frankish suggested that the knife wound may not have been the cause of death, but rather heart failure from shock or even a blood clot on the brain. The jury was not persuaded, however, and Hugh McLeod was found guilty and sentenced to death. But the case had aroused much sympathy for McLeod. His lawyer had not argued for provocation, but his wife had entertained a succession of other men in her bed while he was working up country. A petition was quickly organised and widely signed. McLeod was released from prison later in 1871. Dr Prins, however, was outraged that two young doctors had questioned his competence and professional judgement, and he refused to allow Nedwill or Frankish anywhere near the hospital for many months. The quarrel became public in October 1871 with the publication of correspondence between the provincial government and Drs Nedwill and Frankish in which they called for a public inquiry into the McLeod post mortem. They alleged negligence by Prins for not examining all of the internal organs. They failed to get their inquiry, and Prins was later persuaded to relent and allow them back in the hospital. Source: SURGERY IN NINETEENTH CENTURY CHRISTCHURCH, NEW ZEALAND, 1850-1900. Geoffrey W. Rice, Emeritus Professor of History, University of Canterbury.